At this point, though nothing has been made official, we all have a fairly good idea that Up All Night will never return to television. Christina Applegate quit the show.

Up All Night then underwent another overhaul in Season 2: The Ava Show was canceled, bringing Reagan back home. Arnett's character, a former lawyer, became a contractor.

And “Up All Night” has generally felt like a poster child for that sentiment, with a lot of talented people placed in situations that seemed pleasant but rarely uproarious.

“Up All Night” I am not sold on yet,” said Michael Waymire. Nichelle Stephens observed, “Between ‘Up All Night’ and ‘The New Girl,’ there’s a lot of singing in this season’s ...